|  | enslavement | obedience | discipline | punishment  | endurance | training | humiliation | 
| Novice | temporary slave contributes part of income
 | obeys explicit orders | keeps basic rules | endures medium punishment chained | endures hours of bondage sleeps chained feeds from floor
 | Able to nuzzle, beg, lick, whimper, bark and identify doggy traits to develop. | serves in private & sexually 
 | 
| Intermediate | long-term slavecontributes all income & part of property
 | obeysstanding
 orders
 | behaves & talksformally
 | endures medium punishment unchained & heavy punishment chained. | endures days of bondagesleeps naked in chains
 feeds slave food
 | Can convincingly perform like a dog. Gym training used to overcome short comings.  | serves in publicendures public punishment
 serves third parties sexually
 | 
| Advanced | permanent slave contributes all income & all property
 | obeys automatically, immediately and almost telepathically! | behaves & talks formally automatically | endures heavy pain unchained facial & surprise punishment chained | endures permanent bondage sleeps naked in chains on the floor
 | Dog nature is fully integrated into his persona. Doggy expression is the normal unthinking expression. | endures extreme public humiliation serves third parties sexually in public
 |